Playing up vs. playing down: what a rating gap does to your dynamic rating
Win a league match comfortably, check your dynamic rating the next week, and it has gone down. It feels like a bug. It isn't, and our own numbers show how often it happens.
We looked at every 2026 USTA adult league match in the Tatakai Tennis database where every player had a dynamic rating going in: 532,005 doubles matches and 156,596 singles matches. For each side we worked out how much higher or lower it was rated than the other side, then checked two things: who won, and whether each player's rating went up or down afterwards.
The favorite usually wins, and usually loses rating
When a doubles team was rated 0.4 higher than its opponents, it won 91% of the time. But its players' ratings went down after 57% of those matches and up after only 18%.
The underdogs saw the mirror image. Rated 0.4 lower, they won just 9% of the time, yet their ratings went up after 61% of those matches and down after only 16%.
In an even match the split is close to a coin flip: 40% down, 43% up.
Why winning can cost you rating
A dynamic rating isn't a tally of wins and losses. It moves based on how you played compared with what the ratings predicted. When you're rated well above your opponents, the system already expects a lopsided win. Win 6–4, 6–4 instead of 6–1, 6–1 and you did worse than expected, so your rating slips even though you won.
For the underdog it works the other way. Losing 4–6, 4–6 to a much stronger team is better than expected, so the rating rises without a win. The exact formula isn't published, but the pattern in the results is clear and consistent across every rating gap.
Singles shows the same pattern, a little stronger
In singles, a player rated 0.4 higher won 88% of the time and still saw their rating drop after 66% of matches. Rated 0.4 lower, they won 12% and rose after 66%. With no partner to share the result, the score says more about each player, so the rating reacts more.
What it means for you
Playing down protects your win record, not your rating. To move up, you need to beat lower-rated teams by a wide margin, or hold your own against stronger ones.
Playing up is low risk for your rating. Even in a loss, keeping the score close usually helps.
For captains, a lineup that stacks a strong pair against a weak one wins the court but can drag that pair's ratings down over a season. Close matchups are where ratings move fairly in both directions.
How we measured
Matches from Jan 1 to Nov 21, 2026. Each player's rating going in is their dynamic rating at that match; for doubles a team's rating is the average of the two partners. The gap is rounded to the nearest 0.1 and matches more than 0.4 apart are left out. A rating counts as up or down by comparing it with the player's rating going into their next match; where a row doesn't add to 100%, the rating didn't change. Dynamic ratings are estimates and are not official USTA NTRP ratings.